Don’t Ban Books

I rarely write about “local” events (although “local” blogs are my favorite), but circumstances provoke me tonight. According to Jacksonville’s own Citadel of Truth, First Coast News, Eddie de Oliveira’s novel Lucky is under review by Duval County Public Schools (my Esteemed Employer, I add in the interest of full disclosure). A parent has complained that the book contains “questionable” material and should be banned from the school library. Aparently even in the late oughties the theme of a sexually-confused teenager is “questionable.” According to the (short) report, the parent was particularly offended by “gay themes” and the words “swinger’s party.” The story was barely a blip in the background as the wife and I prepared fresh pesto, so I didn’t catch what particular school said parent’s spawn attends [ed. note–I found out Tuesday morning that the school is none other than LaVilla School of the Arts (emphasis mine)–Jiminy Cricket, what’s up when it’s the art school parents attacking books!] but even if it is an elementary school (which it probably isn’t, not that that matters), banning books from our public school system is regressive at best, and ultimately an abasement of knowledge and intellect. In the past, DCPS has restricted and/or banned The Autobiography of Malcolm X, Catcher in the Rye, Of Mice and Men and at least a dozen more books (I haven’t been able to locate a complete list as of now). Of course, every year many books are challenged (the Harry Potter series springs immediately to mind, and Judy Blume has always caused problems for uptight parents who don’t want to talk honestly with their kids) and as an English teacher I’ve dealt with this in my own classroom, from both parents and administration (an administrator advised [i.e. told] me not to have my students read The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn; another time an administrator was shocked by the diction of Zora Neale Hurston’s classic Their Eyes Were Watching God). This particular mother’s concern is the “questionable” nature of the Lucky‘s themes which might cause readers to uhm, you know, question stuff. If super-mom doesn’t want her kid to read so-and-so, that’s fine with me (and what a great, attentive parent to be all up in the grill of said child’s reading material. Seriously. We (educationeers) really encourage reading with your kids. For real)–but why attempt to ban the book? Why can’t the rest of us make these decisions for ourselves? I could go and on, but I think that my readers don’t need convincing (if you need convincing that banning books is an anti-progress gesture indicative of a caveman mentality, email me at Let’s not add to Jax’s reputation as a bastion of provincial attitudes (particularly in light of recent vagina-controversies): if necessary, we must fight for this book, and every other book’s, place on the library shelf.

For a list of the 100 Most Frequently Challenged Books, go here.

7 thoughts on “Don’t Ban Books”

  1. What is going on down there in J-ville? First the vagina monologues business, and now this???

    Jacksonville is lucky to have people like you that are outraged and will fight to correct this madness. But the scary thing is that those “offended” often fight harder. Don’t let it happen, Jax!

    As a member of the American Library Association, I will support your battle to keep this book on the shelves, should it come to blows. But in light of the fact that you couldn’t find any more information on this than what you heard/saw on the local news, I wonder if it isn’t just another attempt by the local media to create a negative image of nearly everything good and sound that the world has to offer. I hate local news.


  2. Local news is pretty bad. Actually, the national news is even worse: after the local news, we watched NBC national news. After the first twelve minutes of obligatory “hard news,” the newscast devolved into a string of fluff: a report on Brian Williams’s aging father, a piece on the Dixie Chicks, and a human interest story on a skydiver whose shoot didn’t open comprised the last half of “the news.”
    As far as the challenged book goes, what can happen if people don’t fight back is this: DCPS will take the “easy” route. They already have little/no ethical position to begin with, so silencing an annoying parent by removing a book is no big deal to them. However, for those of us who place a value on literature and art, one book banned from a library is a significant step backward. Jacksonville has such a rich literary history that remains largely ignored (James Weldon Johnson and Zora Neale Hurston spring to mind immediately) that it would be a shame if ours was a legacy of censorship.


  3. Hello, it’s the author of Lucky here! Thank you for the support. I didn’t hear about this farce until I stumbled on to your blog, so thanks for raising awareness. I’ve contacted some relevant organisations in Florida who may be able to assist, and I’ll keep you updated on any developments. I’ll also keep my myspace blog up to speed with any news. Fight the power!


Your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.