“Reading is thinking with someone else’s head” (Schopenhauer)

Reading is thinking with someone else’s head instead of one’s own. To think with one’s own head is always to aim at developing a coherent whole—a system, even though it be not a strictly complete one; and nothing hinders this so much as too strong a current of others’ thoughts, such as comes of continual reading. These thoughts, springing every one of them from different minds, belonging to different systems, and tinged with different colors, never of themselves flow together into an intellectual whole; they never form a unity of knowledge, or insight, or conviction; but, rather, fill the head with a Babylonian confusion of tongues. The mind that is over-loaded with alien thought is thus deprived of all clear insight, and is well-nigh disorganized. This is a state of things observable in many men of learning; and it makes them inferior in sound sense, correct judgment and practical tact, to many illiterate persons, who, after obtaining a little knowledge from without, by means of experience, intercourse with others, and a small amount of reading, have always subordinated it to, and embodied it with, their own thought.

From The Art of Literature by Arthur Schopenhauer.

3 thoughts on ““Reading is thinking with someone else’s head” (Schopenhauer)”

  1. Schopenhauer is my favorite philosopher in terms of his views on art. I also like: “Talent hits a target no one else can hit; Genius hits a target no one else can see.”

    Like

  2. That is not always tha case. Many times you identify with certain thoughts who had been already in your mind long ago, but you are confused by other´s people opinions.
    So by reading you just confirm the way you think is right. Who can say that knows how to think?…In ideal case – reading the same as thinking – is neverending searching for truth,until the head and the heart beat in the same rythm.

    Like

Leave a reply to Mick Whitehead Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.