Young Girl of Zsdjar in Sunday Clothes — Marianne Stokes

0_1ff41e_f5744e81_orig

Young Girl of Zsdjar in Sunday Clothes,1909 by Marianne Stokes (1855-1927)

Advertisements

Blog about Balthus’ young girls who read

three-sisters

My young girls who read in dreaming poses are escaping from fleeting, harmful time: KatiaFrederique, and The Three Sisters. Fixing them in the act of reading or dreaming prolongs a privileged, splendid, and magic glimpsed-at time. A suddenly opened curtain sheds light from a window and is seen only by those who know how. Thus a book is a key to open a mysterious trunk containing childhood scents; we rush to open it like the child with butterflies, or the young girl with a moth. It is a gold-sprinkled time that avoids worldly alteration, time nimbused by a magic halo, time fixed in terms of what the smiling, dreaming girls see. It is surreal time in the true sense of the term.

—From Balthus’ 2001 memoir Vanished Splendors, “as told to” Alain Vircondelet. English translation by Benjamin Ivry.

balthus-katia-reading

The first Balthus painting I saw was The Bedroom. I saw it in Edward Lucie-Smith’s Movements in Art since 1945. I was maybe 17, and I found the painting not so much shocking as disturbing. It upset something in me, but I also found myself enchanted by it. In the painting an aesexual woman of dwarfish proportions, scowling and stern, pulls a black curtain to its side to allow sunlight to flood over the nude body of a young woman whose posture is simultaneously sexually vibrant and alarmingly comatose. A cat perched on a book glances out the window. There’s a dark fairy tale embedded in the painting. In its color, light, staging, subject, and theme, it’s of a piece with much of Balthus’ work. I didn’t know that over 20 years ago when I first saw it, but I did know that it intrigued me. I wanted to see more.

three-sisters-1964

As a teenager, Balthus’ visions disturbed and engaged me. My response was aesthetic, but I also found a narrative even in his most static paintings. There’s an eerie peace to his reading girls that I saw then and see now. The rooms he painted were little dreams.

c81d3d4543432d4687cc181c04e2d6f8

Now that I am older I find Balthus’ depictions of girls far, far more disturbing than I did two decades ago. Or rather, I find his paintings disturbing in a different way.

(I think here of rereading Lolita as an adult. I think I first read the book at 15 or 16, and was floored by its language; I read it again in my early 20s—and then in my late twenties. It was a different book).

And yet when I look at Balthus’ paintings of girls reading what emanates most strongly for me is that “gold-sprinkled time that avoids worldly alteration, time nimbused by a magic halo.” He captures something about the private world of reading that I identify with—what I mean is that I feel the feeling of the girls who read in his paintings.

f1c814d0e9f23e6d7165d0bba4910bb3

Elsewhere in his memoir, Balthus declares—

…I completely reject the erotic interpretations that critics and other people have usually made of my paintings. I’ve accomplished my work, paintings and drawings, in which undressed young girls abound, not by exploiting an erotic vision in which I’m a voyeur and surrender unknowingly (above all, unknowingly) to some maniacal or shameful tendencies, but by examining a reality whose profound, risky, and unpredictable unreadability might be shed, revealing a fabulous nature and mythological dimension, a dream world that admits to its own machinery.

Balthus here gives us a fitting description of the “unreadability” of the visions he depicts. Key here is that both his negation (“not by”) and its parallel divergent conjunction (“but by”) frame a perfectly apt analysis of his own work—he is a voyeur, yes, and ushers in a voyeuristic eye—but he also stages a dream world that his viewers can feel.

Two Women in a Garden — Eric Ravilious

two-women-in-a-garden-1933

Two Women in a Garden, 1933 by Eric Ravilious (1903-1942)

Woman Reading — Eastman Johnson

Woman Reading, by Eastman Johnson

Woman Reading, 1874 by Eastman Johnson (1824-1906)

St. Genevieve — Élisabeth Vigée Le Brun

stgenevieve

St. Genevieve, 1793 by Élisabeth Vigée Le Brun (1755—1842)

Girl with Blonde Hair — Helene Schjerfbeck

009L15102_8FFNL_Web

Girl with Blonde Hair, 1916 by Helene Schjerfbeck (1862-1946)

Reading, Whale Point — Stephen Scott Young

6k8c5239

Reading, Whale Point, 2000 by Stephen Scott Young (b. 1957)

The Madonna and Child — William Dyce

1virgin

The Madonna and Child, 1845 by William Dyce (1806–1864)

The Radiance of Attention — Luc Tuymans

the-radiance-of-attention

The Radiance of Attention by Luc Tuymans (b. 1958)

The Reader — Grace Cossington Smith

the-reader-1916.jpg!Large

The Reader, 1916 by Grace Cossington Smith (1908-1971)

Two Girls with a Book — Isabel Bishop

bishop-isabel-1902-1988-two-girls-with-a-book

Lacemaker — Gerrit Dou

G.Dou, Spitzenkloepplerin - G.Dou, Lace maker -

Girl Reading at Window — Henry Moore

Girl Reading at Window 1977-8 by Henry Moore OM, CH 1898-1986

Reader — Francine Van Hove

879c93ba3bac48e60a0133c45eff7fbc

Illuminated Shadows — Chronis Botsoglou

assets_large_t_420_53463739

Untitled — Richard Müller

Courtesan Reading a Letter — Ishikawa Toyonobu