comments 34

Selections from One-Star Amazon Reviews of Melville’s Moby-Dick

[Ed. note: The following citations come from one-star Amazon reviews of Herman Melville’s novel Moby-Dick. To be very clear, I think Moby-Dick is fantasticbut I also enjoy seeing what people compelled to write negative reviews of the book on Amazon had to say. What follows are selections of one-star Amazon reviews; I’ve preserved the reviewers’ unique styles of punctuation and spelling. See also: on Joyce’s Ulysses and Markson’s Wittgenstein’s Mistress].


It made for a smashing movie.

If you want to read lots of meaningless whale trivia read the book.

Boy gets whale. Boy loses whale. Boy gets whale. Spawns yawns

I think if you made it into a short comic strip, you would have liked it.

I bought this book for a friend in jail. Alas, he was unable to read it because the font was too small.

Ray Bradbury, who wrote the screenplay for this novel, (a la Gregory Peck) couldn’t even finish the damn thing!

If you like a story with nonessential information and an author that is entirely to verbose, then this book is for you.

I am quite the fan of stories which involve man eating sea creatures, such as Jaws. Moby Dick is nothing compared to such classics, I fear.

Throughout the book, you may read one chapter with some action only to be followed by 5 or 6 chapters of tangents that are not necessary to understand the story.

Moby Dick, was a horrible waiste of time. Along with its wordy paragraphs, it also talked about uninteresting issues. It is also to long, and you don’t hear of them encountering the whale until the end of the book.

The only people who like this book are english teachers who derive a feeling of moral superiority from forcing others to read this incredibly bad novel.

First of all, classiflying it as fiction is a mistake. Probably a good 60% of the book is non-fiction – chapter after chapter dedicated to every imaginable detail of the biology of the whale and every imaginable nuance of whaling.

I love literatur just as much as the next guy but we must face it 100 years or so ago American literature was reall weak and lagging from the rest of the world, perhaps now they’re starting to catch up with writers like Ann Rice and them.

I have seen better writing in a Hallmark card! Boring! Give me a good ole copy of Elvis and Me! A true story that really tugs at your heart strings! I sleep with that one under my pillow! Keep Moby Dick away from my bed!

Those chapters about Ishmael sleeping with whatever his name was and Ishamel had such a good time with the other guy’s arm over him and leg over him that he didn’t know if he was straight or gay any more.

i personally didn’t enjoy the philosophical or deep side of the book, i have read much much better books in that regard.

There is no suspense, and I find the idea of people hunting whales offensive. Offensive with a capital O.

Honestly, Over 400 pages devoted to killing a whale because it ate your hand? Come on.

It is hard to read. like work. Doubt he could get published today.

What is the whales motivation? You dont know.

It is 540somepages of boring whaling details.

No wonder Melville flopped as a writter.

OMG, this is tedious and torture to read.

I HATE this book. Why? It’s BORING!

Moby Ick’s more like it.


  1. Pingback: Words of One Syllable Dept. | white pebble

  2. Pingback: from biblioklept: one star Amazon reviews of Moby-Dick | remaking moby-dick

  3. Eric

    I must admit, I did skip part of the 40 page dissertation on the color white. That part was a little dry.


  4. Pingback: Selections From One-Star Amazon Reviews Of Melville’s ‘Moby-Dick’ -

  5. Pingback: Selections from One-Star Amazon Reviews of Melville’s Moby-Dick | The Passive Voice | Writers, Writing, Self-Publishing, Disruptive Innovation and the Universe

  6. They should put a section in book stores for those people responsible for posts like this. “Filly-Stines” in bright colorful letters. Stock it with Cliff Notes and Goosebumps. A Mountain Dew vending machine would see a lot of buisness in that aisle.


  7. Pingback: - The Triangle Community

  8. Max Headroom

    Those comments prove that you can’t appreciate a book without studying the history, society and philosophical trends of the period it was written in.
    “Doubt he could get published today” they say. And it’s completely true.


  9. Pingback: Reall Weak and Lagging | G.P. Huffman

  10. Pingback: Newsday Tuesday | Books and Bowel Movements

  11. Otis Axel

    Reblogged this on Pug Butts and commented:
    “Honestly, Over 400 pages devoted to killing a whale because it ate your hand? Come on.”


  12. Pingback: THAT’S NOT EVEN WHAT HE ATE | Pug Butts

  13. Pingback: Literary News and Bookish Potpourri — March 21, 2013 | Vic Books

  14. Pingback: Selections from One-Star Amazon Reviews of Orwell’s 1984 | biblioklept

  15. Pingback: Selections from One-Star Reviews of Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby | biblioklept

  16. Pingback: Mid-Week News Roundup | What I'm Trying to Say

  17. Pingback: The magic number of Amazon book reviews — and the rules of the road | The ACP Blog

  18. Pingback: Monday Medley | No Pun Intended

  19. Pingback: This Year, Read The Best Book In The Whale Wide World | Thought Catalog

  20. Pingback: Selections from One-Star Amazon Reviews of Thomas Pynchon’s Gravity’s Rainbow | Biblioklept

  21. Pingback: Selections from One-Star Amazon Reviews of Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein | Biblioklept

  22. Pingback: Selections from One-Star Amazon Reviews of Chinua Achebe’s Things Fall Apart | Biblioklept

  23. Pingback: Selections from One-Star Amazon Reviews of Thomas Pynchon’s Mason & Dixon | Biblioklept

  24. Pingback: Selections from One-Star Amazon Reviews of Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird | Biblioklept

  25. Pingback: Brigid Brophy et al., Fifty Works of English Literature We Could Do Without | John Pistelli

Your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.