Huxley vs. Orwell: The Webcomic

Stuart McMillen’s webcomic adapts (and updates) Postman’s famous book-length essay, Amusing Ourselves to Death, which argues that Aldous Huxley’s vision of the future in Brave New World was ultimately more accurate than the one proposed by George Orwell in 1984. (Via).

About these ads

56 comments

  1. lionaroundwriting · June 8, 2013

    Very insightful.
    I think both have elements of truth to them without a doubt.

    Huxley may have been more on the head in terms of todays culture. But culture doesn’t pervade for long before something new comes along.

    We are definitely a world of dsitractees – but then, people don’t want to read about why the government wants to spy on our internet activity. They want safe and soft, win tickets to the big weekend, Footballer’s wife loses 1lb – from here nose!

    Like

  2. midatlanticcooking · June 8, 2013

    Reblogged this on Excursions Into Imagination.

    Like

  3. midatlanticcooking · June 8, 2013

    Orwell was right about those who are in power or seeking power and Huxley was right about the culture that allows them to get and remain in power.

    Like

  4. exitotter · June 8, 2013

    Silliman’s Blog. Solid gold. Added to bookmarks.

    Like

  5. Rumplestiltskin · June 8, 2013

    Reblogged this on TheRumplestiltskinReBlog.

    Like

  6. Pingback: Huxley vs. Orwell: The Webcomic | momento
  7. wdclarke · June 8, 2013

    If I remember correctly, Orwell sent 1984 to Huxley, who replied politely that while it was an interesting book, BNW would be our real future

    Like

  8. randomkhaos · June 8, 2013

    Like

  9. seeder68 · June 8, 2013

    Reblogged this on Lies, Liars, Beatniks and Hippies.

    Like

  10. Sabia · June 8, 2013

    I’d say both were right

    We are addicted ad what we love kind of ruin us in a way?

    We see censorship increasing. Look going to a library to read books kind of have a limited range, while with internet the range is bigger, so why access to book online have been getting harder since internet could be the biggest library of actuality? What about mass media and govern censorship of information?

    What about the war of information and misinformation?

    Like

  11. Tim · June 8, 2013

    Thought-provoking.

    In the western world, Huxley’s view has held up (e.g. the US). In dictatorial/autocratic societies, Orwell’s (e.g. North Korea). In religiously-dominated societies a separate vision is appropriate. Has anyone written a Brave New World/1984 dystopian view of a world dominated by religion?

    I guess there’s always 2012, the classic album by Rush – where art and culture and has been banned by a monastic government until a young man or boy with a ludicrously high-pitched voice (Geddy Lee) finds a guitar which miraculously he tunes and works out how to play…

    Like

    • Kino Buster · June 8, 2013

      Completely agree with your first two propositions. Reading Postman in the East Bloc in the ’90s, that became abundantly clear.

      Like

    • Biblioklept · June 8, 2013

      “Has anyone written a Brave New World/1984 dystopian view of a world dominated by religion?”

      —Maybe Atwood’s THE HANDMAIDEN’S TALE?

      Like

      • Tim · June 8, 2013

        Ah yes. I’ve always been meaning to read that. Thanks!

        Like

  12. Pingback: VipPhonecard.com longlivethemagnificentponds: kateoplis: Huxley vs. Orwell the…
  13. radicalleftism · June 8, 2013

    Reblogged this on radicalleftism.

    Like

  14. Pingback: Amusing Ourselves To Death
  15. hong · June 8, 2013

    How about Fahrenheit 451 ?

    Like

  16. Pingback: Le Meilleur des Mondes d’Aldous Huxley | En Vers et Contre-Champs
  17. Pingback: Amusing Ourselves to Death - Something to Think About
  18. thepeerless · June 8, 2013

    Reblogged this on The Peerless and commented:
    What Orwell feared the most eventually became reality.

    Like

  19. Pingback: Orwell vs. Huxley: Who Was More Accurate? – smiling pockets
  20. La Mary · June 8, 2013

    Reblogged this on Ficción y/o Realidad and commented:
    Muy interesante!

    Like

  21. Pingback: Sorry, No. You Are Not Living In Oceania Airstrip One. | Poumista
  22. Pingback: 賴明珠的村上春樹 | beitaizai
  23. NMguiniling · June 8, 2013

    Reblogged this on Ad Astra Comix.

    Like

  24. NMguiniling · June 8, 2013

    Reblogged on Ad Astra Comix.com – website devoted to promoting political comics!

    Like

  25. Engelbert Humperdink · June 8, 2013

    Bit of a misrepresentation. The aim of 1984 was the depiction of and a study into a perfect totalitarian regime, not necessarily the depiction of the legitimate future of world politics, and least of all, the lifestyles of people in a capitalist society. The very order of the names in the title should speak of a hefty authorial bias toward one man.

    Like

  26. Pingback: The Psychedelics and Religion | Life is Mysterious
  27. Pingback: Amani Alkhat
  28. Pingback: | ☆ミ Style Venus Blog
  29. Evelyn WIppich · June 8, 2013

    As a future high school English teacher, I’m very interested in incorporating this webcomic into a lesson plan. Opening the debate to my students would be an excellent opportunity for them. I would love to have this as a poster to hang in my classroom. Do you have such a product available anywhere or are you interested in making such a product available?

    Like

  30. Pingback: Huxley vs Orwell: Amusing Ourselves Into Ruin | ChurchMag
  31. Pingback: Huxley vs Orwell: Amusing Ourselves Into Ruin - Your The Man Jesus
  32. muhamadelfouly · June 8, 2013

    Reblogged this on Muhamad El-Fouly.

    Like

  33. Pingback: fynd NFL football Cykling tröjor 2013
  34. Pingback: Fruzs
  35. Pingback: Is monarchy a superior form of government to modern democracy? - Page 7
  36. Pingback: Thirty Year Gap | The Truth Hurts
  37. Pingback: // lookbacks & mole rats & smarm | // sped
  38. Pingback: ciphanet.eu » le vade-mecum intergalactique
  39. Pingback: Omnium Gatherum: March 5th, 2014 | The Hermetic Library Blog
  40. Pingback: Aldous Huxley vs George Orwell | All over the place
  41. Pingback: Blog de Ruy X.
  42. hkollef · June 8

    Reblogged this on HannahKollef.

    Like

  43. annaholling · June 8

    Reblogged this on OPTIMISTIC ADVENTURES.

    Like

  44. Pingback: The shortcut to the bottom of the barrel | SNTY
  45. tonny · June 8

    All is true in every aspect as they both connot the current situation and our society that we live in its just realisation with a bit more “intellectual depiction on modern society both where right on every aspwct ” we are all slaves to our own desires we all want to fit in…

    Like

  46. dan ashman · June 8

    superb

    Like

  47. direcleit · June 8

    Reblogged this on e-poetry/d-lights and commented:
    An interpretation…

    Like

  48. gregfreed · June 8

    Deserves a “why not both?” meme. As the great divide between my mother and father and their reasons for switching off shows (never mind my own reasons for doing so), the world is too complicated for one or the other to be wholly correct.

    Like

  49. Pingback: Un mundo feliz |
  50. Dave Smith · June 8

    What makes your stuff on the Internet any more relevant than some other stuff on the internet?

    Like

  51. Pingback: Morning coffee: Thursday | Under the Mountain Bunker
  52. Sedate Me · June 8

    Both Orwell and Huxley are completely accurate in their predictions of the future. We live in a world full of drones, cameras, screens that provide endless monitoring of us, secret prisons and Big Brother “keeping us safe” from folks who may not even exist. We also live in a world awash in powerful mood altering drugs that are handed out like candy, a world full of mind numbing distractions and a world where people only care about fulfilling their base urges.

    One thing about 1984 most people forget is that it wasn’t ALL boot-on-the-face. While still under the boot, the Proles were largely ignored because they were too distracted with their pitiful lives and were kept too stupid to pose a threat even if they wanted to. Party Members (Inner & Outer) like Winston Smith were the most watched & most severely punished because they were smart enough to ask questions, seek the truth, or pose a threat. Fear also worked better on them because they were capable of understanding the risks involved with having “bad” thoughts. This is mirrored in life today. Ask too many questions, expose the truth, pose a threat to the established order, and you’ll be targeted for a trip to Room 101. (Just ask Winston SmithBradley Manning or Emmanuel Goldstein Edward Snowden)

    Like

  53. alexcanby · 18 Days Ago

    Both wrote books warning us about possible dystopian futures, but only one impacted us enough to help us avoid that future. Orwell accomplished his end.

    Like

Your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s